100 Christmas Would You Rather Questions
These 100 Christmas would you rather questions serve up funny holiday dilemmas about cookies, lights, gifts, snow and family chaos. Play free with friends: everyone picks a side and the split is revealed with names.
Here are all 100 questions from the 100 Christmas Would You Rather Questions pack for holiday parties. Read them out loud as conversation starters, or start a free room: PartyRoomGames deals the questions, collects everyone's answers on their phones and runs the reveal. Guests join with a room code, no signup.
Play this pack free with friendsPlay this pack free with friends
Pick a social mode:
Log in and we will bring you straight back here with your copy.
Prompts (100)
1. Would you rather eat only cookies for a whole day or eat only mashed potatoes for a whole day?
Food & treatseat only cookies for a whole dayeat only mashed potatoes for a whole day2. Would you rather have hot cocoa that never cools down or have a cookie tin that never runs out?
Food & treatshave hot cocoa that never cools downhave a cookie tin that never runs out3. Would you rather bake cookies with a famous pastry chef or judge a holiday baking contest?
Food & treatsbake cookies with a famous pastry chefjudge a holiday baking contest4. Would you rather eat a holiday dinner made entirely of desserts or eat a holiday dinner with no dessert at all?
Food & treatseat a holiday dinner made entirely of dessertseat a holiday dinner with no dessert at all5. Would you rather give up gravy forever or give up stuffing forever?
Food & treatsgive up gravy forevergive up stuffing forever6. Would you rather have your gingerbread house collapse before the guests arrive or have the guests eat it before you get a photo?
Food & treatshave your gingerbread house collapse before the guests arrivehave the guests eat it before you get a photo7. Would you rather drink peppermint-flavored everything all December or drink pumpkin-spice everything all December?
Food & treatsdrink peppermint-flavored everything all Decemberdrink pumpkin-spice everything all December8. Would you rather cook the entire holiday dinner alone or wash every dish after it alone?
Food & treatscook the entire holiday dinner alonewash every dish after it alone9. Would you rather find a mystery flavor in every cookie or have every cookie taste like a plain sugar cookie?
Food & treatsfind a mystery flavor in every cookiehave every cookie taste like a plain sugar cookie10. Would you rather eat only leftovers until New Year's or never eat leftovers again?
Food & treatseat only leftovers until New Year'snever eat leftovers again11. Would you rather have a hot cocoa bar in your kitchen or have a waffle station in your kitchen?
Food & treatshave a hot cocoa bar in your kitchenhave a waffle station in your kitchen12. Would you rather eat a whole fruitcake by yourself or eat an entire bowl of cranberry sauce?
Food & treatseat a whole fruitcake by yourselfeat an entire bowl of cranberry sauce13. Would you rather frost 100 cookies perfectly or frost 300 cookies messily?
Food & treatsfrost 100 cookies perfectlyfrost 300 cookies messily14. Would you rather have the holiday meal at a fancy restaurant or have a cozy holiday meal at home in pajamas?
Food & treatshave the holiday meal at a fancy restauranthave a cozy holiday meal at home in pajamas15. Would you rather swap the holiday roast for pizza or swap the holiday pie for an ice cream cake?
Food & treatsswap the holiday roast for pizzaswap the holiday pie for an ice cream cake16. Would you rather have every holiday meal be finger food or have every holiday meal be soup?
Food & treatshave every holiday meal be finger foodhave every holiday meal be soup17. Would you rather lose the recipe for your favorite cookie or lose the recipe for your favorite pie?
Food & treatslose the recipe for your favorite cookielose the recipe for your favorite pie18. Would you rather have lights that untangle themselves or have ornaments that never break?
Decorationshave lights that untangle themselveshave ornaments that never break19. Would you rather have the brightest house on the street or have the coziest house on the street?
Decorationshave the brightest house on the streethave the coziest house on the street20. Would you rather decorate with ornaments from your childhood only or decorate with ornaments from your travels only?
Decorationsdecorate with ornaments from your childhood onlydecorate with ornaments from your travels only21. Would you rather hang your tree upside down from the ceiling or put your tree in the bathtub?
Decorationshang your tree upside down from the ceilingput your tree in the bathtub22. Would you rather put lights on every single bush or put one giant inflatable on the roof?
Decorationsput lights on every single bushput one giant inflatable on the roof23. Would you rather find tinsel in your hair all month or find glitter on your hands all month?
Decorationsfind tinsel in your hair all monthfind glitter on your hands all month24. Would you rather keep your decorations up all year or never decorate again?
Decorationskeep your decorations up all yearnever decorate again25. Would you rather smell fresh pine everywhere you go or smell gingerbread everywhere you go?
Decorationssmell fresh pine everywhere you gosmell gingerbread everywhere you go26. Would you rather have a talking ornament or have a tree that sways to music?
Decorationshave a talking ornamenthave a tree that sways to music27. Would you rather turn your car into a sleigh look-alike or turn your mailbox into a snowman?
Decorationsturn your car into a sleigh look-aliketurn your mailbox into a snowman28. Would you rather untangle every strand of lights in the house or replace every burned-out bulb?
Decorationsuntangle every strand of lights in the housereplace every burned-out bulb29. Would you rather squeeze a 20-foot tree into a tiny room or put a one-foot tree in a giant hall?
Decorationssqueeze a 20-foot tree into a tiny roomput a one-foot tree in a giant hall30. Would you rather live next to a neighbor who plays holiday music all day or live next to a neighbor whose lights blink all night?
Decorationslive next to a neighbor who plays holiday music all daylive next to a neighbor whose lights blink all night31. Would you rather choose every decoration but do none of the work or do all the work but choose none of the decorations?
Decorationschoose every decoration but do none of the workdo all the work but choose none of the decorations32. Would you rather have a gentle indoor snowfall in your living room or have a crackling fireplace in every room?
Decorationshave a gentle indoor snowfall in your living roomhave a crackling fireplace in every room33. Would you rather wear a light-up sweater every day of December or wear a jingle-bell hat every day of December?
Decorationswear a light-up sweater every day of Decemberwear a jingle-bell hat every day of December34. Would you rather have ornaments that hum when touched or have ornaments that glow in the dark?
Decorationshave ornaments that hum when touchedhave ornaments that glow in the dark35. Would you rather get one perfect gift or get ten random gifts?
Giftsget one perfect giftget ten random gifts36. Would you rather have a gift-guessing superpower or never be able to guess a single gift?
Giftshave a gift-guessing superpowernever be able to guess a single gift37. Would you rather always give the perfect gift or always receive the perfect gift?
Giftsalways give the perfect giftalways receive the perfect gift38. Would you rather wrap presents for the whole family or shop for the whole family?
Giftswrap presents for the whole familyshop for the whole family39. Would you rather open every present at midnight or open them one at a time all day long?
Giftsopen every present at midnightopen them one at a time all day long40. Would you rather get a heartfelt handwritten letter or get a fancy new gadget?
Giftsget a heartfelt handwritten letterget a fancy new gadget41. Would you rather get a gift that's useful every day or get a gift that's fun once a year?
Giftsget a gift that's useful every dayget a gift that's fun once a year42. Would you rather have unlimited wrapping paper but no tape or have unlimited tape but only newspaper?
Giftshave unlimited wrapping paper but no tapehave unlimited tape but only newspaper43. Would you rather accidentally see your own gift early or accidentally spoil someone else's gift?
Giftsaccidentally see your own gift earlyaccidentally spoil someone else's gift44. Would you rather give a small gift to a stranger every day in December or get one surprise gift every week of the year?
Giftsgive a small gift to a stranger every day in Decemberget one surprise gift every week of the year45. Would you rather open a giant box with a tiny gift inside or open a tiny box with a giant surprise inside?
Giftsopen a giant box with a tiny gift insideopen a tiny box with a giant surprise inside46. Would you rather have every gift come with a riddle or have every gift hidden on a scavenger hunt?
Giftshave every gift come with a riddlehave every gift hidden on a scavenger hunt47. Would you rather get the same gift as your sibling or get a gift your sibling wants more than you do?
Giftsget the same gift as your siblingget a gift your sibling wants more than you do48. Would you rather forget to buy one person a gift or buy one person a gift that's way off?
Giftsforget to buy one person a giftbuy one person a gift that's way off49. Would you rather unwrap a present with 20 layers of paper or unwrap a present sealed with an entire roll of tape?
Giftsunwrap a present with 20 layers of paperunwrap a present sealed with an entire roll of tape50. Would you rather pick your own gifts but wait until summer or get surprise gifts right on time?
Giftspick your own gifts but wait until summerget surprise gifts right on time51. Would you rather receive one gift from each friend or receive one big gift from all your friends together?
Giftsreceive one gift from each friendreceive one big gift from all your friends together52. Would you rather get a snow day every Monday all winter or get snow on Christmas morning every single year?
Snow & winterget a snow day every Monday all winterget snow on Christmas morning every single year53. Would you rather sled down a mountain or ice skate across a frozen lake?
Snow & wintersled down a mountainice skate across a frozen lake54. Would you rather build a snowman as tall as your house or carve a snow slide down your whole street?
Snow & winterbuild a snowman as tall as your housecarve a snow slide down your whole street55. Would you rather be snowed in at a cabin for a week or be stuck at an airport for a day?
Snow & winterbe snowed in at a cabin for a weekbe stuck at an airport for a day56. Would you rather never feel cold again or never have to shovel again?
Snow & winternever feel cold againnever have to shovel again57. Would you rather have warm toes all winter or have warm hands all winter?
Snow & winterhave warm toes all winterhave warm hands all winter58. Would you rather ride in a horse-drawn sleigh or ride on a snowmobile?
Snow & winterride in a horse-drawn sleighride on a snowmobile59. Would you rather wake up to fresh powder or wake up to frost patterns on every window?
Snow & winterwake up to fresh powderwake up to frost patterns on every window60. Would you rather go snowshoeing all day or stay inside by the fire all day?
Snow & wintergo snowshoeing all daystay inside by the fire all day61. Would you rather have a snowball that never melts or have a snowman that follows you around?
Snow & winterhave a snowball that never meltshave a snowman that follows you around62. Would you rather spend Christmas in a snowy mountain village or spend Christmas in a big city full of lights?
Snow & winterspend Christmas in a snowy mountain villagespend Christmas in a big city full of lights63. Would you rather wear a snowsuit to every event or wear flip-flops in the snow?
Snow & winterwear a snowsuit to every eventwear flip-flops in the snow64. Would you rather be a professional snowman builder or be a professional ice sculptor?
Snow & winterbe a professional snowman builderbe a professional ice sculptor65. Would you rather have it snow only on weekends or have it snow only at night?
Snow & winterhave it snow only on weekendshave it snow only at night66. Would you rather lose your hat on the coldest day of the year or lose your scarf on the coldest day of the year?
Snow & winterlose your hat on the coldest day of the yearlose your scarf on the coldest day of the year67. Would you rather shovel snow for an hour or scrape ice off a car for an hour?
Snow & wintershovel snow for an hourscrape ice off a car for an hour68. Would you rather see the northern lights on Christmas Eve or see a shooting star on Christmas Eve?
Snow & wintersee the northern lights on Christmas Evesee a shooting star on Christmas Eve69. Would you rather host every family holiday or never host but always travel?
Family traditionshost every family holidaynever host but always travel70. Would you rather have a snowy picnic on Christmas morning or have an indoor campout on Christmas Eve?
Family traditionshave a snowy picnic on Christmas morninghave an indoor campout on Christmas Eve71. Would you rather take the family photo in the snow or take the family photo in front of the fireplace?
Family traditionstake the family photo in the snowtake the family photo in front of the fireplace72. Would you rather know every line of one holiday movie or see every holiday movie just once?
Family traditionsknow every line of one holiday moviesee every holiday movie just once73. Would you rather have a quiet Christmas with a few people or have a loud Christmas with 40 relatives?
Family traditionshave a quiet Christmas with a few peoplehave a loud Christmas with 40 relatives74. Would you rather play board games all evening or go singing door to door in the neighborhood?
Family traditionsplay board games all eveninggo singing door to door in the neighborhood75. Would you rather bake with your grandparents or decorate with your cousins?
Family traditionsbake with your grandparentsdecorate with your cousins76. Would you rather be the one who reads the holiday story aloud or be the one who hands out all the presents?
Family traditionsbe the one who reads the holiday story aloudbe the one who hands out all the presents77. Would you rather invent a new family tradition this year or bring back one from your grandparents' childhood?
Family traditionsinvent a new family tradition this yearbring back one from your grandparents' childhood78. Would you rather drive 10 hours to see family or have 10 relatives stay at your house for a week?
Family traditionsdrive 10 hours to see familyhave 10 relatives stay at your house for a week79. Would you rather set the table for 20 people or clear the table after 20 people?
Family traditionsset the table for 20 peopleclear the table after 20 people80. Would you rather sit at the kids' table forever or sit next to the chattiest relative every year?
Family traditionssit at the kids' table foreversit next to the chattiest relative every year81. Would you rather visit a holiday lights drive-through or wander through a holiday market?
Family traditionsvisit a holiday lights drive-throughwander through a holiday market82. Would you rather take the family photo every year or be in every family photo with your eyes closed?
Family traditionstake the family photo every yearbe in every family photo with your eyes closed83. Would you rather sleep in on Christmas morning or be the very first one awake?
Family traditionssleep in on Christmas morningbe the very first one awake84. Would you rather have a family talent show or have a family cook-off?
Family traditionshave a family talent showhave a family cook-off85. Would you rather be one of Santa's reindeer for a day or be one of Santa's helpers for a day?
Silly what-ifsbe one of Santa's reindeer for a daybe one of Santa's helpers for a day86. Would you rather have a voice that jingles or have hair that sparkles like tinsel?
Silly what-ifshave a voice that jingleshave hair that sparkles like tinsel87. Would you rather live inside a snow globe or live inside a toy shop?
Silly what-ifslive inside a snow globelive inside a toy shop88. Would you rather hold Santa's list for your whole town or borrow Santa's sleigh for one night?
Silly what-ifshold Santa's list for your whole townborrow Santa's sleigh for one night89. Would you rather be able to talk to snowmen or be able to talk to reindeer?
Silly what-ifsbe able to talk to snowmenbe able to talk to reindeer90. Would you rather grow a beard like Santa's for a week or wear a suit like Santa's every day?
Silly what-ifsgrow a beard like Santa's for a weekwear a suit like Santa's every day91. Would you rather shrink to the size of an ornament for a day or grow as tall as the tree for a day?
Silly what-ifsshrink to the size of an ornament for a daygrow as tall as the tree for a day92. Would you rather find a tiny door inside your Christmas tree or find a secret tunnel to the North Pole?
Silly what-ifsfind a tiny door inside your Christmas treefind a secret tunnel to the North Pole93. Would you rather deliver every gift on Earth in one night or wrap every gift on Earth in one month?
Silly what-ifsdeliver every gift on Earth in one nightwrap every gift on Earth in one month94. Would you rather have it be Christmas every day or have Christmas only once every five years?
Silly what-ifshave it be Christmas every dayhave Christmas only once every five years95. Would you rather have reindeer as next-door neighbors or have penguins as next-door neighbors?
Silly what-ifshave reindeer as next-door neighborshave penguins as next-door neighbors96. Would you rather swap houses with Santa for a week or swap jobs with Santa for a day?
Silly what-ifsswap houses with Santa for a weekswap jobs with Santa for a day97. Would you rather have a snowman as your best friend or have a gingerbread person as your best friend?
Silly what-ifshave a snowman as your best friendhave a gingerbread person as your best friend98. Would you rather have a laugh that sounds like sleigh bells or have a sneeze that makes it snow?
Silly what-ifshave a laugh that sounds like sleigh bellshave a sneeze that makes it snow99. Would you rather slide down a chimney or ride in a sleigh pulled by flying penguins?
Silly what-ifsslide down a chimneyride in a sleigh pulled by flying penguins100. Would you rather have every day smell like fresh cookies or have every day sound like sleigh bells?
Silly what-ifshave every day smell like fresh cookieshave every day sound like sleigh bells
Rate this pack
Create a free account to rate and report packs.
Related packs
Keep the room going with another safe, ready-to-play theme.