100 Halloween Would You Rather Questions
Halloween would you rather questions about itchy wigs, candy trades, friendly ghost roommates and talking jack-o'-lanterns. Play free with friends at your party: everyone votes, then the reveal shows who picked what.
Here are all 100 questions from the 100 Halloween Would You Rather Questions pack for holiday parties. Read them out loud as conversation starters, or start a free room: PartyRoomGames deals the questions, collects everyone's answers on their phones and runs the reveal. Guests join with a room code, no signup.
Play this pack free with friendsPlay this pack free with friends
Pick a social mode:
Log in and we will bring you straight back here with your copy.
Prompts (100)
1. Would you rather wear a costume that lights up or wear a costume that squeaks every time you move?
Costumeswear a costume that lights upwear a costume that squeaks every time you move2. Would you rather dress up as a giant pumpkin or dress up as a walking candy bar?
Costumesdress up as a giant pumpkindress up as a walking candy bar3. Would you rather wear a fluffy costume on a warm night or wear a thin costume on a freezing night?
Costumeswear a fluffy costume on a warm nightwear a thin costume on a freezing night4. Would you rather show up in the same costume as your best friend or show up in the same costume as your grandparent?
Costumesshow up in the same costume as your best friendshow up in the same costume as your grandparent5. Would you rather wear a homemade cardboard costume or wear a fancy store-bought costume?
Costumeswear a homemade cardboard costumewear a fancy store-bought costume6. Would you rather stay in your costume for an entire week or change costumes every hour on Halloween night?
Costumesstay in your costume for an entire weekchange costumes every hour on Halloween night7. Would you rather win the costume contest in a costume you hate or lose it in a costume you love?
Costumeswin the costume contest in a costume you hatelose it in a costume you love8. Would you rather wear a cape that keeps tripping you or wear a mask that keeps fogging up?
Costumeswear a cape that keeps tripping youwear a mask that keeps fogging up9. Would you rather have a group costume with ten friends or have a solo costume nobody can guess?
Costumeshave a group costume with ten friendshave a solo costume nobody can guess10. Would you rather wear face paint that won't wash off for three days or wear a wig that itches all night?
Costumeswear face paint that won't wash off for three dayswear a wig that itches all night11. Would you rather dress your pet as a hot dog or dress your pet as a tiny dragon?
Costumesdress your pet as a hot dogdress your pet as a tiny dragon12. Would you rather have a costume that makes you truly invisible or have a costume that lets you fly for one night?
Costumeshave a costume that makes you truly invisiblehave a costume that lets you fly for one night13. Would you rather wear a costume with a tail that knocks things over or wear one with wings that get stuck in doorways?
Costumeswear a costume with a tail that knocks things overwear one with wings that get stuck in doorways14. Would you rather get only chocolate in your candy bag or get only sour candy?
Candy & treatsget only chocolate in your candy bagget only sour candy15. Would you rather get one giant candy bar or get fifty tiny ones?
Candy & treatsget one giant candy barget fifty tiny ones16. Would you rather trade your whole candy haul for a large pizza or keep every last piece?
Candy & treatstrade your whole candy haul for a large pizzakeep every last piece17. Would you rather be the house that gives out full-size candy bars or be the house that gives out homemade caramel apples?
Candy & treatsbe the house that gives out full-size candy barsbe the house that gives out homemade caramel apples18. Would you rather eat candy corn every day for a month or never eat candy corn again?
Candy & treatseat candy corn every day for a monthnever eat candy corn again19. Would you rather find a toothbrush in your candy bag or find a box of raisins?
Candy & treatsfind a toothbrush in your candy bagfind a box of raisins20. Would you rather have a candy bag that never gets heavy or have a candy bag that refills once a day?
Candy & treatshave a candy bag that never gets heavyhave a candy bag that refills once a day21. Would you rather get pumpkin spice flavor in everything you eat or have a Halloween with no sweets at all?
Candy & treatsget pumpkin spice flavor in everything you eathave a Halloween with no sweets at all22. Would you rather eat a caramel apple with no stick or eat a popcorn ball that sticks to your teeth all night?
Candy & treatseat a caramel apple with no stickeat a popcorn ball that sticks to your teeth all night23. Would you rather trick-or-treat at houses giving out apples or trick-or-treat at houses giving out tiny pencils?
Candy & treatstrick-or-treat at houses giving out applestrick-or-treat at houses giving out tiny pencils24. Would you rather eat a gummy worm the size of a real snake or eat a hundred gummy worms the size of ants?
Candy & treatseat a gummy worm the size of a real snakeeat a hundred gummy worms the size of ants25. Would you rather share your candy with your whole street or hide your stash so well you forget where it is?
Candy & treatsshare your candy with your whole streethide your stash so well you forget where it is26. Would you rather spend a night in a haunted house or spend a night lost in a corn maze?
Haunted housesspend a night in a haunted housespend a night lost in a corn maze27. Would you rather ride a haunted hayride or walk through a haunted house with wobbly floors?
Haunted housesride a haunted hayridewalk through a haunted house with wobbly floors28. Would you rather live in a haunted house with a friendly ghost or live in a normal house with a grumpy neighbor?
Haunted houseslive in a haunted house with a friendly ghostlive in a normal house with a grumpy neighbor29. Would you rather have a ghost roommate who cleans up after you or have a ghost roommate who hums off-key all night?
Haunted houseshave a ghost roommate who cleans up after youhave a ghost roommate who hums off-key all night30. Would you rather hear creaky footsteps every night or find doors swinging open every morning?
Haunted houseshear creaky footsteps every nightfind doors swinging open every morning31. Would you rather explore a spooky attic or explore a spooky basement?
Haunted housesexplore a spooky atticexplore a spooky basement32. Would you rather be the actor who jumps out to scare people or be the visitor walking through?
Haunted housesbe the actor who jumps out to scare peoplebe the visitor walking through33. Would you rather walk through a foggy forest at midnight or walk through an empty school at midnight?
Haunted houseswalk through a foggy forest at midnightwalk through an empty school at midnight34. Would you rather open a door that leads to a room full of spiders or open a door that leads to a room full of bats?
Haunted housesopen a door that leads to a room full of spidersopen a door that leads to a room full of bats35. Would you rather have portraits whose eyes follow you or have a piano that plays by itself?
Haunted houseshave portraits whose eyes follow youhave a piano that plays by itself36. Would you rather be a vampire who only drinks tomato juice or be a werewolf who only changes on Tuesdays?
Monstersbe a vampire who only drinks tomato juicebe a werewolf who only changes on Tuesdays37. Would you rather have a pet bat or have a pet black cat?
Monstershave a pet bathave a pet black cat38. Would you rather be best friends with a mummy or be best friends with a swamp monster?
Monstersbe best friends with a mummybe best friends with a swamp monster39. Would you rather be a witch whose broom is afraid of heights or be a wizard whose spells only work on vegetables?
Monstersbe a witch whose broom is afraid of heightsbe a wizard whose spells only work on vegetables40. Would you rather have a monster living under your bed or have a monster living in your closet?
Monstershave a monster living under your bedhave a monster living in your closet41. Would you rather turn into a werewolf whenever a dog barks or turn into a bat whenever you sneeze?
Monstersturn into a werewolf whenever a dog barksturn into a bat whenever you sneeze42. Would you rather have a ghost who tells terrible jokes or have a skeleton who never stops dancing?
Monstershave a ghost who tells terrible jokeshave a skeleton who never stops dancing43. Would you rather be able to talk to ghosts or be able to walk through walls like one?
Monstersbe able to talk to ghostsbe able to walk through walls like one44. Would you rather be a mummy who keeps unraveling or be a ghost who can't stop hiccuping?
Monstersbe a mummy who keeps unravelingbe a ghost who can't stop hiccuping45. Would you rather own a cauldron that makes any soup you want or own a crystal ball that shows tomorrow's weather?
Monstersown a cauldron that makes any soup you wantown a crystal ball that shows tomorrow's weather46. Would you rather be a zombie who only craves broccoli or be a vampire who is scared of garlic bread?
Monstersbe a zombie who only craves broccolibe a vampire who is scared of garlic bread47. Would you rather be chased by a very slow zombie for a year or be chased by a very fast one for a minute?
Monstersbe chased by a very slow zombie for a yearbe chased by a very fast one for a minute48. Would you rather ride a flying broomstick or ride on the back of a giant friendly bat?
Monstersride a flying broomstickride on the back of a giant friendly bat49. Would you rather be a monster who is scared of kids or be a kid who scares every monster?
Monstersbe a monster who is scared of kidsbe a kid who scares every monster50. Would you rather give your jack-o'-lantern a goofy grin or give it a spooky frown?
Pumpkinsgive your jack-o'-lantern a goofy gringive it a spooky frown51. Would you rather carve the scariest pumpkin on the block or carve the funniest one?
Pumpkinscarve the scariest pumpkin on the blockcarve the funniest one52. Would you rather eat pumpkin pie at every meal for a week or never taste pumpkin again?
Pumpkinseat pumpkin pie at every meal for a weeknever taste pumpkin again53. Would you rather live inside a giant pumpkin or live inside a gingerbread cottage?
Pumpkinslive inside a giant pumpkinlive inside a gingerbread cottage54. Would you rather scoop out pumpkin seeds with your bare hands or scoop them out with a teaspoon?
Pumpkinsscoop out pumpkin seeds with your bare handsscoop them out with a teaspoon55. Would you rather grow the biggest pumpkin at the fair or grow the tiniest pumpkin in the world?
Pumpkinsgrow the biggest pumpkin at the fairgrow the tiniest pumpkin in the world56. Would you rather have a jack-o'-lantern that talks or have a jack-o'-lantern that glows any color you choose?
Pumpkinshave a jack-o'-lantern that talkshave a jack-o'-lantern that glows any color you choose57. Would you rather go to a pumpkin patch with a hayride or go to one with a giant slide?
Pumpkinsgo to a pumpkin patch with a hayridego to one with a giant slide58. Would you rather carve twenty pumpkins in one night or carve one masterpiece that takes all week?
Pumpkinscarve twenty pumpkins in one nightcarve one masterpiece that takes all week59. Would you rather go trick-or-treating or stay home and hand out candy?
Spooky nightgo trick-or-treatingstay home and hand out candy60. Would you rather watch a spooky movie alone or watch it next to your jumpiest friend?
Spooky nightwatch a spooky movie alonewatch it next to your jumpiest friend61. Would you rather tell ghost stories around a campfire or go on a flashlight hunt in the dark?
Spooky nighttell ghost stories around a campfirego on a flashlight hunt in the dark62. Would you rather host a Halloween party or go to someone else's?
Spooky nighthost a Halloween partygo to someone else's63. Would you rather decorate with fake spiderwebs everywhere or decorate with a thousand tiny pumpkins?
Spooky nightdecorate with fake spiderwebs everywheredecorate with a thousand tiny pumpkins64. Would you rather bob for apples or race to eat a doughnut hanging on a string?
Spooky nightbob for applesrace to eat a doughnut hanging on a string65. Would you rather have Halloween in the middle of summer or have it during a snowstorm?
Spooky nighthave Halloween in the middle of summerhave it during a snowstorm66. Would you rather have a full moon every Halloween or have a thunderstorm every Halloween?
Spooky nighthave a full moon every Halloweenhave a thunderstorm every Halloween67. Would you rather trick-or-treat in pouring rain or trick-or-treat in deep snow?
Spooky nighttrick-or-treat in pouring raintrick-or-treat in deep snow68. Would you rather live in the scariest house on the street or live in the house with the best candy?
Spooky nightlive in the scariest house on the streetlive in the house with the best candy69. Would you rather hear a wolf howl outside your window or hear something scratching at the door?
Spooky nighthear a wolf howl outside your windowhear something scratching at the door70. Would you rather read a spooky story out loud or listen to one in a pitch-dark room?
Spooky nightread a spooky story out loudlisten to one in a pitch-dark room71. Would you rather walk the trick-or-treat route with a map or wander and see where the night takes you?
Spooky nightwalk the trick-or-treat route with a mapwander and see where the night takes you72. Would you rather have a fog machine in every room or have spooky sound effects playing all night?
Spooky nighthave a fog machine in every roomhave spooky sound effects playing all night73. Would you rather sneeze glitter all of October or hiccup tiny bats?
Silly scenariossneeze glitter all of Octoberhiccup tiny bats74. Would you rather have a black cat cross your path every day or have a crow follow you everywhere?
Silly scenarioshave a black cat cross your path every dayhave a crow follow you everywhere75. Would you rather be the only one in costume on the wrong day or forget to dress up when everyone else did?
Silly scenariosbe the only one in costume on the wrong dayforget to dress up when everyone else did76. Would you rather keep a pet tarantula or keep a pet snake?
Silly scenarioskeep a pet tarantulakeep a pet snake77. Would you rather find a plastic spider in your shoe or find one in your hat?
Silly scenariosfind a plastic spider in your shoefind one in your hat78. Would you rather have a skeleton as your best friend or have a scarecrow as your best friend?
Silly scenarioshave a skeleton as your best friendhave a scarecrow as your best friend79. Would you rather stand as a scarecrow in a field for a day or pose as a statue in a haunted museum?
Silly scenariosstand as a scarecrow in a field for a daypose as a statue in a haunted museum80. Would you rather get a jump scare every hour or never be able to feel scared again?
Silly scenariosget a jump scare every hournever be able to feel scared again81. Would you rather be able to turn into a black cat or be able to turn into an owl?
Silly scenariosbe able to turn into a black catbe able to turn into an owl82. Would you rather have glow-in-the-dark teeth or have glow-in-the-dark hair?
Silly scenarioshave glow-in-the-dark teethhave glow-in-the-dark hair83. Would you rather have a costume that changes every time you blink or pick one costume forever?
Silly scenarioshave a costume that changes every time you blinkpick one costume forever84. Would you rather ring a doorbell answered by a robot or ring one answered by a talking parrot?
Silly scenariosring a doorbell answered by a robotring one answered by a talking parrot85. Would you rather get stuck in a corn maze with a chatty scarecrow or get stuck in a hay-bale fort with a nosy crow?
Silly scenariosget stuck in a corn maze with a chatty scarecrowget stuck in a hay-bale fort with a nosy crow86. Would you rather have a witch's hat that tells jokes or have a magic wand that only makes bubbles?
Silly scenarioshave a witch's hat that tells jokeshave a magic wand that only makes bubbles87. Would you rather wake up with vampire fangs for a week or wake up with werewolf ears for a week?
Silly scenarioswake up with vampire fangs for a weekwake up with werewolf ears for a week88. Would you rather have every door creak loudly or have every floor squeak loudly?
Silly scenarioshave every door creak loudlyhave every floor squeak loudly89. Would you rather meet a ghost who wants to learn to dance or meet a vampire who wants to learn to bake?
Silly scenariosmeet a ghost who wants to learn to dancemeet a vampire who wants to learn to bake90. Would you rather swap houses with a friendly witch for a night or swap places with a haunted-house ghost for a night?
Silly scenariosswap houses with a friendly witch for a nightswap places with a haunted-house ghost for a night91. Would you rather win the costume parade or win the pumpkin-carving contest?
Party gameswin the costume paradewin the pumpkin-carving contest92. Would you rather play mummy wrap with toilet paper or play pin the nose on the witch?
Party gamesplay mummy wrap with toilet paperplay pin the nose on the witch93. Would you rather decorate spooky cupcakes or decorate spooky sugar cookies?
Party gamesdecorate spooky cupcakesdecorate spooky sugar cookies94. Would you rather have a monster-themed dance party or have a midnight scavenger hunt?
Party gameshave a monster-themed dance partyhave a midnight scavenger hunt95. Would you rather guess the mystery object in a dark box or be the one who picks what goes inside it?
Party gamesguess the mystery object in a dark boxbe the one who picks what goes inside it96. Would you rather make a haunted house out of a cardboard box or make a haunted house out of graham crackers?
Party gamesmake a haunted house out of a cardboard boxmake a haunted house out of graham crackers97. Would you rather have a party with a fortune teller or have a party with a magician?
Party gameshave a party with a fortune tellerhave a party with a magician98. Would you rather plan the spookiest party playlist or plan the spookiest party snacks?
Party gamesplan the spookiest party playlistplan the spookiest party snacks99. Would you rather wear a blindfold through a mini haunted hallway or lead your blindfolded friends through it?
Party gameswear a blindfold through a mini haunted hallwaylead your blindfolded friends through it100. Would you rather stay up for a Halloween movie marathon or wake up early for a Halloween pancake breakfast?
Party gamesstay up for a Halloween movie marathonwake up early for a Halloween pancake breakfast
Rate this pack
Create a free account to rate and report packs.
Related packs
Keep the room going with another safe, ready-to-play theme.