100 Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions
Thanksgiving would you rather questions with real dilemmas: endless gravy or endless stuffing, hosting 30 in a tiny apartment or a 10-hour drive, and a 1621 time trip. Play free with friends and see who picked which side.
Here are all 100 questions from the 100 Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions pack for holiday parties. Read them out loud as conversation starters, or start a free room: PartyRoomGames deals the questions, collects everyone's answers on their phones and runs the reveal. Guests join with a room code, no signup.
Play this pack free with friendsPlay this pack free with friends
Pick a social mode:
Log in and we will bring you straight back here with your copy.
Prompts (100)
1. Would you rather have endless gravy but no stuffing or endless stuffing but no gravy?
The feasthave endless gravy but no stuffingendless stuffing but no gravy2. Would you rather carve the turkey in front of everyone or mash 20 pounds of potatoes by hand?
The feastcarve the turkey in front of everyonemash 20 pounds of potatoes by hand3. Would you rather eat the whole Thanksgiving meal with only a spoon or with only chopsticks?
The feastwith only a spoonwith only chopsticks4. Would you rather have the whole dinner served as tiny appetizers or as one giant casserole?
The feastas tiny appetizersas one giant casserole5. Would you rather only eat foods that are orange or only eat foods that are brown on Thanksgiving?
The feastonly eat foods that are orangeonly eat foods that are brown6. Would you rather wake up at 5 a.m. to start the turkey or stay up until 2 a.m. finishing the pies?
The feastwake up at 5 a.m. to start the turkeystay up until 2 a.m. finishing the pies7. Would you rather have every dish be a little too salty or a little too sweet?
The feasta little too saltya little too sweet8. Would you rather sip gravy from a mug or eat cranberry sauce from a bowl like soup?
The feastsip gravy from a mugeat cranberry sauce from a bowl like soup9. Would you rather cook the holiday meal in a tiny camper kitchen or over a backyard fire pit?
The feastin a tiny camper kitchenover a backyard fire pit10. Would you rather roast one turkey the size of a car or a hundred turkeys the size of a teacup?
The feastone turkey the size of a cara hundred turkeys the size of a teacup11. Would you rather skip the turkey entirely or skip all the side dishes?
The feastskip the turkey entirelyskip all the side dishes12. Would you rather eat Thanksgiving dinner at a fancy restaurant or at home in sweatpants?
The feastat a fancy restaurantat home in sweatpants13. Would you rather have a personal chef for the day or a personal dishwasher for the day?
The feasta personal chef for the daya personal dishwasher for the day14. Would you rather sit down for the big meal at 11 a.m. or at 9 p.m.?
The feastat 11 a.m.at 9 p.m.15. Would you rather be allowed only one plate or unlimited plates with just one food on each?
The feastonly one plateunlimited plates with just one food on each16. Would you rather your rolls always come out slightly burned or slightly doughy?
The feastslightly burnedslightly doughy17. Would you rather be famous across town for your gravy or for your stuffing?
The feastfor your gravyfor your stuffing18. Would you rather eat leftovers for a week straight or never have leftovers again?
Pie & leftoverseat leftovers for a week straightnever have leftovers again19. Would you rather have a pie that is all crust or a pie that is all filling?
Pie & leftoversa pie that is all crusta pie that is all filling20. Would you rather get the very last slice of pumpkin pie or the first slice of a fresh apple pie?
Pie & leftoversthe very last slice of pumpkin piethe first slice of a fresh apple pie21. Would you rather never put a topping on pie again or put whipped cream on every meal for a month?
Pie & leftoversnever put a topping on pie againput whipped cream on every meal for a month22. Would you rather bake ten pies in one day or taste ten different pies in one day?
Pie & leftoversbake ten pies in one daytaste ten different pies in one day23. Would you rather have a fridge that magically refills with leftovers or a dishwasher that loads itself?
Pie & leftoversa fridge that magically refills with leftoversa dishwasher that loads itself24. Would you rather eat a leftover sandwich the size of your head or a bowl of turkey soup the size of a bathtub?
Pie & leftoversa leftover sandwich the size of your heada bowl of turkey soup the size of a bathtub25. Would you rather accidentally sit on a pie or accidentally drop the turkey on the floor?
Pie & leftoversaccidentally sit on a pieaccidentally drop the turkey on the floor26. Would you rather take home all the leftovers but do all the dishes or take none home and do none of the dishes?
Pie & leftoverstake home all the leftovers but do all the dishestake none home and do none of the dishes27. Would you rather share your pie with the whole table or get a mini pie nobody else can touch?
Pie & leftoversshare your pie with the whole tableget a mini pie nobody else can touch28. Would you rather have pie at every meal for three days or never eat pie again?
Pie & leftovershave pie at every meal for three daysnever eat pie again29. Would you rather invent a brand-new pie flavor or perfect the classic pumpkin recipe?
Pie & leftoversinvent a brand-new pie flavorperfect the classic pumpkin recipe30. Would you rather eat your leftovers cold from the fridge or wait 20 minutes for them to reheat in the oven?
Pie & leftoverseat your leftovers cold from the fridgewait 20 minutes for them to reheat in the oven31. Would you rather find out your favorite pie was store-bought or find out it hid a secret vegetable?
Pie & leftoversfind out your favorite pie was store-boughtfind out it hid a secret vegetable32. Would you rather turn the leftover turkey into soup or into a pot pie?
Pie & leftoversinto soupinto a pot pie33. Would you rather lose the last piece of pie to a sibling or to the family dog?
Pie & leftoversto a siblingto the family dog34. Would you rather compete in a no-hands pie-eating contest or a pie-baking contest against a pro baker?
Pie & leftoversa no-hands pie-eating contesta pie-baking contest against a pro baker35. Would you rather write a thank-you note to everyone at the table or give a one-minute thank-you speech?
Gratitudewrite a thank-you note to everyone at the tablegive a one-minute thank-you speech36. Would you rather hear what everyone is thankful for about you or tell everyone what you're thankful for about them?
Gratitudehear what everyone is thankful for about youtell everyone what you're thankful for about them37. Would you rather get one sincere compliment from every guest or one small homemade gift from every guest?
Gratitudeone sincere compliment from every guestone small homemade gift from every guest38. Would you rather spend Thanksgiving morning serving food at a community kitchen or host a meal for neighbors who would otherwise eat alone?
Gratitudeserving food at a community kitchenhost a meal for neighbors who would otherwise eat alone39. Would you rather get a surprise thank-you letter from an old teacher or write one to them?
Gratitudeget a surprise thank-you letter from an old teacherwrite one to them40. Would you rather remember every kind thing anyone has ever said to you or forget every embarrassing thing you've ever done?
Gratituderemember every kind thing anyone has ever said to youforget every embarrassing thing you've ever done41. Would you rather start a family gratitude jar this year or a yearly thank-you video tradition?
Gratitudea family gratitude jara yearly thank-you video tradition42. Would you rather say what you're thankful for in a rhyme or with a little dance?
Gratitudein a rhymewith a little dance43. Would you rather be thanked in front of everyone at dinner or privately with a long note?
Gratitudebe thanked in front of everyone at dinnerprivately with a long note44. Would you rather thank the cook with a standing ovation or by doing every last dish?
Gratitudewith a standing ovationby doing every last dish45. Would you rather write down five things you're thankful for every night or say one out loud every morning?
Gratitudewrite down five things you're thankful for every nightsay one out loud every morning46. Would you rather be known as the most thankful person in the family or the most helpful one?
Gratitudethe most thankful person in the familythe most helpful one47. Would you rather get a heartfelt letter from a grandparent or a goofy video message from a cousin?
Gratitudea heartfelt letter from a grandparenta goofy video message from a cousin48. Would you rather relive your best Thanksgiving ever or peek at what Thanksgiving will look like in 30 years?
Gratituderelive your best Thanksgiving everpeek at what Thanksgiving will look like in 30 years49. Would you rather say what you're thankful for first or go last after everyone else?
Gratitudesay what you're thankful for firstgo last after everyone else50. Would you rather thank someone who helped you this year with a homemade meal or with a handmade card?
Gratitudewith a homemade mealwith a handmade card51. Would you rather sit next to the toddler who flings peas or the relative who tells very long stories?
Family tablethe toddler who flings peasthe relative who tells very long stories52. Would you rather be in charge of the seating chart or the cleanup schedule?
Family tablethe seating chartthe cleanup schedule53. Would you rather host 30 people in a tiny apartment or drive 10 hours to someone else's house?
Family tablehost 30 people in a tiny apartmentdrive 10 hours to someone else's house54. Would you rather have a dinner where everyone must speak in rhymes or everyone must whisper?
Family tableeveryone must speak in rhymeseveryone must whisper55. Would you rather answer every relative's questions about your plans or look at every photo on your aunt's phone?
Family tableanswer every relative's questions about your planslook at every photo on your aunt's phone56. Would you rather play a board game that lasts four hours or play charades with the most competitive relative?
Family tableplay a board game that lasts four hoursplay charades with the most competitive relative57. Would you rather wash every dish by hand or dry and put away every dish?
Family tablewash every dish by handdry and put away every dish58. Would you rather be the official family photographer or the official turkey carver?
Family tablethe official family photographerthe official turkey carver59. Would you rather sit at the kids' table forever or be in charge of the kids' table forever?
Family tablesit at the kids' table foreverbe in charge of the kids' table forever60. Would you rather spend Thanksgiving with only your cousins or with only your grandparents?
Family tablewith only your cousinswith only your grandparents61. Would you rather hear the same family story five times or be asked the same question by five relatives?
Family tablehear the same family story five timesbe asked the same question by five relatives62. Would you rather host a family talent show after dinner or a family trivia contest after dinner?
Family tablea family talent showa family trivia contest63. Would you rather keep all the little kids busy during dinner or cook the entire meal by yourself?
Family tablekeep all the little kids busy during dinnercook the entire meal by yourself64. Would you rather go to a 50-person family reunion Thanksgiving or have a quiet dinner for two?
Family tablea 50-person family reunion Thanksgivinga quiet dinner for two65. Would you rather always be the first guest to arrive or always be the last guest to leave?
Family tablealways be the first guest to arrivealways be the last guest to leave66. Would you rather eat at a table with no chairs or on chairs with no table?
Family tableat a table with no chairson chairs with no table67. Would you rather run the family group chat or run the family photo album?
Family tablerun the family group chatrun the family photo album68. Would you rather pick a whole bushel of apples or carve ten pumpkins?
Fall & harvestpick a whole bushel of applescarve ten pumpkins69. Would you rather rake an entire yard of leaves or shovel the first snow of the season?
Fall & harvestrake an entire yard of leavesshovel the first snow of the season70. Would you rather live where it is fall all year or where it is summer all year?
Fall & harvestwhere it is fall all yearwhere it is summer all year71. Would you rather take a hayride under the stars or a sunrise hike through the fall colors?
Fall & harvesttake a hayride under the starsa sunrise hike through the fall colors72. Would you rather wear a giant scarf every day or fuzzy boots every day?
Fall & harvesta giant scarf every dayfuzzy boots every day73. Would you rather give up pumpkin flavor until next fall or give up apple flavor until next fall?
Fall & harvestgive up pumpkin flavorgive up apple flavor74. Would you rather sit around a bonfire with friends or have a cozy movie marathon under blankets?
Fall & harvestsit around a bonfire with friendshave a cozy movie marathon under blankets75. Would you rather watch the leaves change in the mountains or watch the waves at a quiet November beach?
Fall & harvestwatch the leaves change in the mountainswatch the waves at a quiet November beach76. Would you rather grow your own pumpkins or grow your own cranberries?
Fall & harvestgrow your own pumpkinsgrow your own cranberries77. Would you rather jump into a huge leaf pile or build a giant leaf fort?
Fall & harvestjump into a huge leaf pilebuild a giant leaf fort78. Would you rather smell like a pumpkin candle forever or like fresh-baked bread forever?
Fall & harvestlike a pumpkin candle foreverlike fresh-baked bread forever79. Would you rather spend November in a cabin in the woods or in a busy big city?
Fall & harvestin a cabin in the woodsin a busy big city80. Would you rather take a fall road trip to see the leaves or a fall camping trip?
Fall & harvesta fall road trip to see the leavesa fall camping trip81. Would you rather carve a pumpkin with your eyes closed or paint one with your feet?
Fall & harvestcarve a pumpkin with your eyes closedpaint one with your feet82. Would you rather have every tree turn bright red or every tree turn golden yellow?
Fall & harvestevery tree turn bright redevery tree turn golden yellow83. Would you rather spend a day working on a real farm or a day at a packed fall festival?
Fall & harvesta day working on a real farma day at a packed fall festival84. Would you rather wear flannel every day until New Year's or a sweater vest every day until New Year's?
Fall & harvestflannel every daya sweater vest every day85. Would you rather have a pet turkey that follows you everywhere or a pet squirrel that steals your snacks?
Silly what-ifsa pet turkey that follows you everywherea pet squirrel that steals your snacks86. Would you rather float as a balloon in the parade or be one of the people holding the balloon ropes?
Silly what-ifsfloat as a balloon in the paradebe one of the people holding the balloon ropes87. Would you rather speak only in gobbles for an hour or strut like a turkey for an hour?
Silly what-ifsspeak only in gobbles for an hourstrut like a turkey for an hour88. Would you rather have gravy come out of your kitchen faucet or have cranberry sauce rain from the sky?
Silly what-ifshave gravy come out of your kitchen faucethave cranberry sauce rain from the sky89. Would you rather celebrate Thanksgiving on the moon or on a submarine?
Silly what-ifson the moonon a submarine90. Would you rather turn into a turkey for a day or into a pumpkin pie for a day?
Silly what-ifsinto a turkey for a dayinto a pumpkin pie for a day91. Would you rather time-travel to see the 1621 harvest feast at Plymouth or see Thanksgiving in the year 3000?
Silly what-ifssee the 1621 harvest feast at Plymouthsee Thanksgiving in the year 300092. Would you rather have a robot cook your Thanksgiving dinner or a robot clean up afterward?
Silly what-ifsa robot cook your Thanksgiving dinnera robot clean up afterward93. Would you rather have Thanksgiving every month or one Thanksgiving that lasts a whole week?
Silly what-ifshave Thanksgiving every monthone Thanksgiving that lasts a whole week94. Would you rather eat the whole meal blended into a smoothie or squeezed into one bite-sized cube?
Silly what-ifsblended into a smoothiesqueezed into one bite-sized cube95. Would you rather own a gravy boat big enough to ride in or a pie big enough to nap on?
Silly what-ifsa gravy boat big enough to ride ina pie big enough to nap on96. Would you rather be able to taste any dish just by smelling it or cook any dish just by looking at it?
Silly what-ifstaste any dish just by smelling itcook any dish just by looking at it97. Would you rather win a lifetime supply of stuffing or a lifetime supply of pie?
Silly what-ifsa lifetime supply of stuffinga lifetime supply of pie98. Would you rather be chased by a wild turkey or by a flock of honking geese?
Silly what-ifsa wild turkeya flock of honking geese99. Would you rather invent a machine that peels potatoes or one that scrubs roasting pans?
Silly what-ifsa machine that peels potatoesone that scrubs roasting pans100. Would you rather find a wishbone that grants one real wish or a pie that refills every time you take a slice?
Silly what-ifsa wishbone that grants one real wisha pie that refills every time you take a slice
Rate this pack
Create a free account to rate and report packs.
Related packs
Keep the room going with another safe, ready-to-play theme.