75 Thanksgiving Most Likely To Questions

Prompts (75)

• 1. Who is most likely to fill half their plate with mashed potatoes?

  The feast

• 2. Who is most likely to start eating before everyone sits down?

  The feast

• 3. Who is most likely to forget to turn the oven on?

  The feast

• 4. Who is most likely to ask what is in every single dish before trying it?

  The feast

• 5. Who is most likely to drown everything on their plate in gravy?

  The feast

• 6. Who is most likely to set a kitchen timer and then completely ignore it?

  The feast

• 7. Who is most likely to bring a dish nobody has ever heard of?

  The feast

• 8. Who is most likely to volunteer to carve the turkey without knowing how?

  The feast

• 9. Who is most likely to make a whole meal out of rolls and butter?

  The feast

• 10. Who is most likely to taste-test so much they are full before dinner starts?

  The feast

• 11. Who is most likely to sneak a pinch of stuffing straight from the pan?

  The feast

• 12. Who is most likely to try a wild new recipe on the big day instead of practicing first?

  The feast

• 13. Who is most likely to bring the exact same dish every single year?

  The feast

• 14. Who is most likely to bake an extra pie just for themselves?

  Pie & leftovers

• 15. Who is most likely to hide a slice of pie in the fridge for later?

  Pie & leftovers

• 16. Who is most likely to write their name on every leftover container?

  Pie & leftovers

• 17. Who is most likely to build a giant leftover sandwich at midnight?

  Pie & leftovers

• 18. Who is most likely to insist on trying one slice of every pie?

  Pie & leftovers

• 19. Who is most likely to leave with more containers than they came with?

  Pie & leftovers

• 20. Who is most likely to put whipped cream on things that are not dessert?

  Pie & leftovers

• 21. Who is most likely to still be eating leftovers a week later?

  Pie & leftovers

• 22. Who is most likely to start a long argument about which pie is best?

  Pie & leftovers

• 23. Who is most likely to drop a pie on the way to the car?

  Pie & leftovers

• 24. Who is most likely to invent a strange new recipe with the leftovers?

  Pie & leftovers

• 25. Who is most likely to eat the filling and leave the crust behind?

  Pie & leftovers

• 26. Who is most likely to get teary while saying what they are thankful for?

  Gratitude

• 27. Who is most likely to say they are thankful for naps?

  Gratitude

• 28. Who is most likely to give a full speech instead of a quick thank-you?

  Gratitude

• 29. Who is most likely to mail thank-you cards after the holiday?

  Gratitude

• 30. Who is most likely to invite someone who has nowhere else to go for the holiday?

  Gratitude

• 31. Who is most likely to thank the cook five separate times?

  Gratitude

• 32. Who is most likely to make everyone write a gratitude note before dessert?

  Gratitude

• 33. Who is most likely to zone out and miss their turn to share what they're thankful for?

  Gratitude

• 34. Who is most likely to say they are thankful for their pet before any person?

  Gratitude

• 35. Who is most likely to call an old friend just to say thanks?

  Gratitude

• 36. Who is most likely to leave little thank-you sticky notes around the house?

  Gratitude

• 37. Who is most likely to turn a heartfelt thank-you into a joke?

  Gratitude

• 38. Who is most likely to sneak away from the grown-ups to play with the kids?

  Family table

• 39. Who is most likely to tell the same story every single year?

  Family table

• 40. Who is most likely to win every after-dinner board game?

  Family table

• 41. Who is most likely to disappear right when it's time to do the dishes?

  Family table

• 42. Who is most likely to round everyone up for the family photo?

  Family table

• 43. Who is most likely to blink in the family photo?

  Family table

• 44. Who is most likely to arrive late with a very creative excuse?

  Family table

• 45. Who is most likely to start a friendly debate at the table?

  Family table

• 46. Who is most likely to make the kids laugh the loudest?

  Family table

• 47. Who is most likely to show up in a matching fall outfit with someone else?

  Family table

• 48. Who is most likely to cheer way too loudly at the football game on TV?

  Family table

• 49. Who is most likely to ask for the family recipe and never make it?

  Family table

• 50. Who is most likely to bring a surprise guest without warning anyone?

  Family table

• 51. Who is most likely to turn raking leaves into a competition?

  Fall & harvest

• 52. Who is most likely to wander off the path at a fall festival?

  Fall & harvest

• 53. Who is most likely to put up winter decorations before Thanksgiving?

  Fall & harvest

• 54. Who is most likely to wear a scarf when it isn't even cold?

  Fall & harvest

• 55. Who is most likely to pick the biggest pumpkin in the patch and regret carrying it?

  Fall & harvest

• 56. Who is most likely to order everything pumpkin-flavored?

  Fall & harvest

• 57. Who is most likely to take a hundred photos of fall leaves?

  Fall & harvest

• 58. Who is most likely to wear a turkey-print sweater with pride?

  Fall & harvest

• 59. Who is most likely to press apples into homemade cider?

  Fall & harvest

• 60. Who is most likely to plan a fall hike right after the big meal?

  Fall & harvest

• 61. Who is most likely to bring home way too many apples from the orchard?

  Fall & harvest

• 62. Who is most likely to start a pinecone collection?

  Fall & harvest

• 63. Who is most likely to give the turkey a name?

  Silly what-ifs

• 64. Who is most likely to win a pie-eating contest?

  Silly what-ifs

• 65. Who is most likely to try to bend the rules of the wishbone pull?

  Silly what-ifs

• 66. Who is most likely to lead the parade if they got the chance?

  Silly what-ifs

• 67. Who is most likely to show up in a fancy outfit for a casual dinner?

  Silly what-ifs

• 68. Who is most likely to frame a hand-traced turkey drawing?

  Silly what-ifs

• 69. Who is most likely to plan their holiday shopping list during dinner?

  Silly what-ifs

• 70. Who is most likely to turn cooking the leftovers into a pretend cooking show?

  Silly what-ifs

• 71. Who is most likely to get gravy on their shirt?

  Silly what-ifs

• 72. Who is most likely to stretch a long weekend into a whole week off?

  Silly what-ifs

• 73. Who is most likely to be caught dancing in the kitchen?

  Silly what-ifs

• 74. Who is most likely to narrate the turkey carving like a sports announcer?

  Silly what-ifs

• 75. Who is most likely to build a centerpiece out of things from the backyard?

  Silly what-ifs

Related packs

Keep the room going with another safe, ready-to-play theme.

• Thanksgiving75 Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions for Kids75 prompts
• Thanksgiving100 Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions100 prompts
• Thanksgiving30 Thanksgiving Icebreaker Questions for Work30 prompts